When the Career You've Built Takes an Unexpected Turn
In 1998, Jamie Dimon was president of Citigroup. He'd spent 16 years working alongside Sandy Weill, starting at American Express and helping build what would become one of the largest financial institutions in the world.
He was widely expected to succeed Weill as CEO. Then Weill asked him to resign.
Think about that for a minute. You've spent 16 years building something, you're in line for the top job, and suddenly you're out.
I've worked with senior leaders in financial services for 25 years, and I've seen versions of this play out many times. A restructuring eliminates your role. A new CEO brings in their own people. Your sponsor leaves. Or the position you've been working toward goes to someone else.
When that happens, it's natural to want to get back to where you were. You want a comparable title, at a comparable firm, with the same level of responsibility. I totally get that. You've spent 20 or 25 years building your career, and you don't want to feel like you're starting over.
But I'd ask you to think about something.
What are you actually trying to get back? Is it the title, the standing you had inside the firm, or the opportunity to do work that matters and be recognized for it?
And before you start looking for the next role, have you thought about whether those are still the things you want?
Why Dimon Chose a Struggling Bank
Dimon spent roughly 18 months considering his options. He met with Jeff Bezos about a role at Amazon and explored opportunities at Home Depot.
In March 2000, he chose Bank One in Chicago.
Bank One had serious problems. Years of mergers had left it with operational challenges, its credit-card business was struggling, and investor confidence had deteriorated.
Dimon moved his family to Chicago and invested nearly $57 million of his own money in the company's stock.
Bank One reported a $511 million loss in 2000. By 2003, it earned $3.5 billion. In 2004, JPMorgan Chase acquired Bank One, and Dimon became CEO of the combined firm on January 1, 2006.
Now, I don't know everything that went into his decision, and I wouldn't suggest that taking over a troubled bank was some guaranteed path to JPMorgan.
There were real risks, and things could have turned out differently.
But I think his decision raises an important question for anyone considering their next senior role.
Are you evaluating the opportunity based on what you're trying to get back, or what you actually want to accomplish next?
Because those two things can lead you in very different directions.
What Firms Look for When They Hand Someone More Responsibility
When I was in corporate, and in the work I've done with clients since, I've seen how much this distinction matters.
Every firm has difficult problems that need someone to take responsibility for them. It might be a business that's losing market share, a transformation that's already been restarted twice, or an integration that hasn't delivered what everyone expected.
And when senior leadership is deciding who gets more responsibility, they're thinking about who they can trust to deal with those problems.
They want someone who understands the business, can work across the organization, and can get things done when the answer isn't obvious.
I've seen this with clients as well. One was displaced during a restructuring and went on to become Head of Legal.
Every situation is different, of course. But what I've seen repeatedly is that losing a role can create an opportunity to reconsider what you want from the next stage of your career.
Maybe you still want to run a larger business. Maybe you want more direct influence over decisions. Maybe the work matters more to you now than the size of the institution. Or maybe you've reached a point where what you're willing to give up for the next promotion has changed.
There's nothing wrong with any of those answers.
The important thing is understanding why you're making the decision, rather than allowing what happened in your last role to make it for you.
And once you've thought about what you want, you still need to make a good business decision.
A difficult assignment without the authority, resources, or support to succeed can cost you years. You need to understand what you're walking into and whether the firm is genuinely committed to fixing the problem.
I wouldn't encourage anyone to take a struggling business simply because it offers a bigger challenge.
You have to want the opportunity, and the conditions have to give you a reasonable chance of succeeding.
Start With What You Want to Accomplish Next
If you've lost a senior role, or you're thinking about leaving one, I'd encourage you to spend some time on this before you begin evaluating opportunities.
Start by asking yourself what you want the next five or ten years of your career to look like.
What kind of work do you want to be doing? What responsibilities do you want? What would you like to accomplish that you haven't had the opportunity to do yet?
And what are you willing, or no longer willing, to give up to get there?
Once you have a better sense of that, look at the opportunities in front of you.
Does the role give you the chance to do the work you want to do? Are there meaningful problems you're well equipped to solve? Will you have the authority and support you need?
And assuming you do the job well, what does that create for the firm? What does it create for you?
You may discover that the opportunity you initially dismissed is exactly what you're looking for.
Or you may decide that the prestigious role you've been pursuing doesn't actually give you what you want anymore.
Both are useful things to learn before making a commitment.
Seven years after leaving Citigroup, Dimon was preparing to become CEO of JPMorgan Chase. He got there after spending four years leading the turnaround of a bank that had serious problems when he arrived.
We can't know everything Dimon wanted when he made that decision. But his experience is a useful reminder that an unexpected career change can give you the chance to reconsider where you want to go.
So if you're thinking about what comes next, I'd ask you to separate two things.
What are you trying to recover from your last role?
And what do you actually want to accomplish in the next stage of your career?
Take some time to answer both. Then look at the opportunities you're considering and see which ones will help you accomplish what matters to you now.
If you want a clear read on what the next level requires from you specifically, book a 30-minute Introduction & Assessment with me:
Key takeaways
Jamie Dimon was asked to resign as Citigroup's president in 1998 and became CEO of JPMorgan Chase on January 1, 2006.
After leaving Citigroup, he spent about 18 months considering options, including Amazon and Home Depot, before choosing Bank One, a bank with serious problems.
When a senior role ends unexpectedly, the natural instinct is to get back a comparable title, firm, and level of responsibility.
Separating what you're trying to recover from what you want to accomplish next leads to better decisions about the next role.
A difficult assignment only makes sense if you want it and the firm gives you the authority, resources, and support to succeed.
FAQ
Why was Jamie Dimon fired from Citigroup?
After the 1998 merger of Travelers and Citicorp, Sandy Weill asked Dimon, then Citigroup's president, to resign. Dimon had worked alongside Weill for 16 years and was widely expected to succeed him as CEO.
What did Jamie Dimon do after he left Citigroup?
He spent about 18 months considering his options, met with Jeff Bezos about a role at Amazon, explored Home Depot, and became chairman and CEO of Bank One in Chicago in March 2000.
How much did Jamie Dimon invest in Bank One?
He bought 2 million shares of Bank One stock for nearly $57 million of his own money when he took the job.
How did Jamie Dimon become CEO of JPMorgan Chase?
Bank One went from a $511 million loss in 2000 to $3.5 billion in earnings in 2003. JPMorgan Chase acquired Bank One in 2004, and Dimon became CEO of the combined firm on January 1, 2006.
What should a senior leader do after losing a role?
Before evaluating opportunities, decide what you want the next five or ten years to look like, what work and responsibilities you want, and what you're no longer willing to give up. Then test each opportunity against that.
Should I take on a struggling business to advance my career?
Only if you want the opportunity and the conditions give you a reasonable chance to succeed. A difficult assignment without the authority, resources, or support it needs can cost you years, so understand what you're walking into and whether the firm is committed to fixing the problem.
About Brian Rella
Brian Rella is the founder of EverNext and a leadership advisor to VPs through C-Suite in financial services. After 25 years at Wells Fargo, BGC, Bloomberg, HSBC, JP Morgan, and UBS, he helps senior leaders own the mandates their firms most need and be recognized and rewarded at the next level.

